Something I have been learning about myself recently: if someone says I am supposed to do some specific thing, or that that thing is a requirement – that sort of hard and fast language – then I will tend to do that thing if I can manage it, no matter how difficult, tedious, or pointlessly overkill it seems
It turns out that in the real world (or at least many parts of it), no one works on this basis. People who give strict-sounding instructions assume that when they say you “have to” do X, almost no one will actually do X, and most people will do part of X and not the whole thing. They then scale up their demands to anticipate this. Often, when someone says “you must do these 10 things,” and you actually do all 10 things, they will act impressed but a bit scared and perhaps ask concerned questions about how much sleep and free time you’re getting
This is baffling to me! The reason is that if I meet the stated “requirement,” I know I’m safe. I did what was asked, and the asker / the world can’t complain, or rather they can complain but not about that aspect of things. If I’m supposed to decide on my own how much to violate the stated rule, how the hell am I supposed to know what is the “right” amount of non-compliance? When you say “10,” do you mean “3 is fine and 5 would be great,” or do you mean “5 is perfectly sufficient but 3 will make everything explode,” or “most people will do 5 to 7 but I’m keeping my eye out for the really great productive people who do 9-10,” or …
I don’t have a cost function! Just tell me the cost function! What am I supposed to do, make one up? You’re the one who knows what your standards are based on, not me!
So then realistically you get these cases where people casually say “oh yeah you have to do this absurdly difficult thing, have it on my desk tomorrow morning” and I know that even if I could do it, I can’t just blow all my time and energy and stress-credits on every suspicious request like this that comes along, and so I do a half-assed job of 40% of the thing and then am left in a state of anxious uncertainty until I get a response. Did I embarrass myself? Did I heroically go above and beyond the call of duty? Who knows?!?!
Meanwhile there are apparently people who just do the 40% (or 20%, or 80%) and think “yeah, that seems about right” and feel perfectly fine with that assumption? I guess? How??



