Personally, I never knew “liberal” was as a derogatory term by the left until after college, when I started reading communists online.
(I did hear “neoliberal” a lot, but that’s quite different, and used much more widely)
Very few people in America seem aware of what the “hard left” is actually like. The mainstream right does worry about communism, but tends to emphasize (real or imagined) coalitions and unities rather than splits (cf. Horowitz’s “Discover The Networks” site) – they mostly tend to claim that the center left is actually a front for communism, or allied with communism, or some other variant on the idea of a “vast left-wing conspiracy,” with “communism” also assumed to be internally united.
Looking at the other side of the picture: I don’t think the American mainstream left is very aware of divisions on the “hard right” either, and tends to lump everything together as well. But the “hard right” at least has enough of a presence that the typical Democratic voter learns to distinguish (proverbially) between their non-doctrinaire but very racist grandpa, their fundamentalist homeschooling aunt, and their uncle in the Marines who thinks civilians of all stripes are all weak and could use some military discipline.
Many people know that the left has schisms, at least well enough to laugh at the “People’s Front of Judea” joke, but they still tend to think of all hard-leftists as (1) equally marginal and ignorable, (2) distant and indistinguishable but vaguely “cool” allies, or (3) a united coalition of evil.
almostcoralchaos reblogged this from nostalgebraist
allocrow liked this
timtotal liked this
tentativelyassembled liked this
thathopeyetlives reblogged this from rangi42 and added:
I don’t endorse this generally but it’s interesting and important.
witandmirth liked this
xhxhxhx liked this
nostalgebraist liked this
hylleddin liked this
rangi42 liked this
nuclearspaceheater liked this
surpluscornbread liked this
ymawgat liked this
wirehead-wannabe liked this
estinadaemon reblogged this from slatestarscratchpad
estinadaemon liked this neuroflux liked this
femmenietzsche liked this oldwordcubed liked this
theceilingunlimited liked this
deathchrist2000 liked this
tossedsalad-scrambledeggs reblogged this from slatestarscratchpad and added: “The Black Panthers are violent criminals” Are you sure you don’t mean Thugs
eccentric-opinion liked this
gattsuru reblogged this from nostalgebraist and added:
That’s true to an extent. Even as someone that actively tries to follow a lot of hard-left folk, both adjacent to the...
magfrump reblogged this from nostalgebraist and added:
I am a vaguely politically active person (admittedly born and raised in some of the most “liberal” parts of California...
kerapace liked this
voidprimer liked this
isaacsapphire reblogged this from marcusseldon and added:
Just chiming in as a person raised as a Fundamentalist homeshooler, milita-adjacent, not-not-pals with racists and...
girlpoasts liked this
slatestarscratchpad reblogged this from nostalgebraist and added:
I’m still not sure what you mean. I don’t think most people can distinguish eg Rothbardians from Hayekians, or Sailerite...
starlightvero reblogged this from nostalgebraist and added:
This seems roughly correct to me.
nostalgebraist reblogged this from hamiltonianflow and added:
In America (unlike everwhere else?), “liberal” colloquially just means “left,” with no other connotations. I’m sure...
centralkvetchmonolith liked this
- Show more notes
