Install Theme

It’s always weird to me how I see all these arguments on here about “charity to one’s enemies,” and whether this is some sort of subcultural nerd fetish, or, like, a reactionary thing, or whatever, when the most extreme versions of “charity to one’s enemies” espoused online are basically classed under “don’t be a dick” by most people I’ve encountered IRL

Like, obviously not everyone succeeds at this 100% of the time, but it seems widely accepted as an obviously good thing among everyone I know who isn’t some sort of hardcore internet argument junkie

  1. nostalgebraist reblogged this from lovecrafts-iranon and added:
    I meant “not all hardcore internet argument junkies accept this as an obviously good thing, but all of the people who...
  2. lovecrafts-iranon reblogged this from nostalgebraist and added:
    What exactly do you mean by hardcore internet argument junkie? Because by my definition, most rationalists fit. So the...
  3. uncrediblehallq reblogged this from waystatus
  4. waystatus reblogged this from uncrediblehallq and added:
    I agree with this, and would like to add that a lot of the charity stuff seems to be taking for granted a level of...
  5. sigmaleph reblogged this from nostalgebraist and added:
    Ok, yeah, people are much more dickish to people they are talking to when online. But, and I might be wrong here, isn’t...
  6. nothingismere reblogged this from slatestarscratchpad
  7. formerbishie reblogged this from shlevy
  8. dataandphilosophy reblogged this from jaiwithanadult and added:
    Steel-manning isn’t replacing your opponent’s argument with a better one, it’s replacing your opponent’s argument with...
  9. mugasofer reblogged this from sigmaleph
  10. jaiwithanadult reblogged this from sigmaleph and added:
    The Principle of Charity is *not* don’t be a dick, but “interpret rhetoric and arguments from your opponents in the most...
  11. davy-the-sorcerer-blog reblogged this from sigmaleph and added:
    In my experience, it depends if the outgroup is *present*; if they’re not, and everyone present is ingroup, charity is...