Install Theme

argumate:

rowan-canyon:

argumate:

If you want to be a dick, hang around philosophers and claim not to have qualia.

“What is this consciousness thing you keep rabbiting on about?”

“Do I have it? How can I tell?”

cackling at the devilishness of this post

also cackling at the dearth of pertinent google results for “how can i tell if i have qualia”

P-Zombies don’t have qualia, but they suffer a strange affliction that compels them to insist that they do.

In one of Steven Pinker’s books (I think it was How The Mind Works) he tells an anecdote about how a friend once “confessed” to him that he was actually a p-zombie.  (”I lost all conscious experience after a head injury in childhood.”)  Pinker said he thought it was a joke, but of course there was no way to know for sure.

(via argumate)

  1. dharma-initiative-official reblogged this from nostalgebraist
  2. voxette-vk reblogged this from argumate and added:
    I don’t know if you’re using “consciousness” to mean something different, but people are conscious in the relevant sense...
  3. argumate reblogged this from argumate and added:
    every time you are conscious you lose the game
  4. jabyrwock reblogged this from thatdamnpipsqueak
  5. thatdamnpipsqueak reblogged this from fallen-scientist
  6. ofmonstersandmintcookies reblogged this from jiskblr and added:
    Oop just remembered this. I have a couple things to say in response to this.There’s a thought experiment that goes like...
  7. jiskblr reblogged this from ofmonstersandmintcookies and added:
    Well, if you insist…What is ‘redness’ and how is it distinct from the signals my eyes send when light bounces off a red...
  8. cromulentenough reblogged this from nostalgebraist
  9. moral-autism reblogged this from argumate and added:
    I did this, sort of: “[exhales in a way that matches the way in which people exhale when they claim to be relieved]”